User talk:Siachi

Good Job

Dear Siachi,

Let me first say thank you for fighting off this editor. He has been causing problems and I thank you for undoing his edits. Here is a little "weapon" you can use. It is good to bring up things to a SysOp and you should, but in the mean time you can mark his pages with the following template.

   {{Template:Delete|why=Reason Why} }

Simply remove the space with the last }. This will mark the page for deletion. SysOps often check the "To delete" page and will instantly see what he has done.

Again, thank you for standing up to him.

With Respect,

-- ^{~My Page} // ^{My Talk} // ^Contribs 01:20, 18 August 2010 (UTC)

Thank you

I've marked up some of the pages of his for deletion. I forgot to remove the redirections, so I'm fixing that right now.

Re: This is Siachi, who is probably dragging himself into a flame-war

Dear Siachi,

Let me first say that I am on neither your nor Nitroryan77's "side". I am a arbitrator, which means I will not take sides in a this dispute but I will listens to both sides and works to resolve the situation. As "flame-war" as their own are not allowed on this wiki, via the Rules, I will try to handle this issue quickly and defuse the problem as best as I can before you BOTH are removed from the wiki.

Your Argument: "As an editor I have a right to edit any page unless protected or specified otherwise. Also, The page is question, Queen of All Monsters, is not a monster in game yet and therefore should not be listed on this wiki."

*You are correct in believing that as an editor and member of this wiki you do have a right to edit pages. Also, monsters that are not in game often are not allowed on this wiki. I agree with you completely except for a step you forgot. Due to the fact that anyone can edit most anything you do have to remember a bit of respect. I think you lacked to think through that what you simply blanked was someone's hard work.

Nitroryan77's Argument:'' "I created a page, Queen of All Monsters, and therefore it is my page. No one should edit it. The items are not yet in game but are theories and have been voted on."

*I did say we would mark the page as a theory and try to leave it up there. My thought would be that no one would think it out of place. I believe that there could be a better place for it now as it is true that monsters that are not in game are not suppose to be on the wiki. I am currently pondering making a "Theory Page" special for such ideas. I do think you worked hard on the page and spent a good amount of time researching this beast before you created it, but the common use of the wiki still stands. Unless by special privilege or rank, no page can be protected and therefore can be edited by ANY person with an account on this wiki. Also, theories can be misleading if placed somewhere where they do not belong. I do understand that you only had the right purpose at heart but I believe you simply made a mistake. Also, I am not a "lawyer".

My advice:

*After pondering this issue for some time I have decided that the best course of action is to follow.

1. I ask that Siachi issues Nitroryan77 an apology for blanking his page without asking him first what the point, purpose, and idea behind the page was. This is a small lack of respect and is very hurtful to someone who worked hard on a special page.

2. I ask that Nitroryan77 move your theory work to a special page linked to your user page. This page is Nitroryan77's Monster Theories. This way, you can still have your page and your personal work but it will not be in the way or in a section where it doesn't belong.

3. I ask that after both of these are done, you BOTH make amends and put this behind you. If there is something else then work it out, CALMLY, between yourselves. If another fight breaks out I will be forced to bring Higher Powers into this. They, unlike myself, will not hesitate to ban anyone from the wiki.

With Hope,

-- ^{~My Page} // ^{My Talk} // ^Contribs 02:03, 19 August 2010 (UTC)